Analysis or Property Value Changes on English Drive and Kingswood Drive, Bainbridge, Ohio, on or within 2000 feet of the December 15, 2007 Explosion during Hydraulic Fracturing (Fraking)

Source: Geauga County Auditors Office, English Drive, Kingswood Drive
Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources, Bainbridge Investigation

Property Value Summary

  • 66% of homes experienced dramatic home value decreases within 2000 feet of incident

  • 33% of homes devalued about 60% or higher

  • 33% of homes devalued between 40% and 60%
  • Neighborhood property value decrease of $3.31 million dollars

  • Ohio Valley Energy systems owns the home that was severely damaged

  • Only 1 house on English and one on Kingswood have sold since incident, NEITHER HAD NO PROPERTY VALUE DECREASE FROM 2006 TO 2009, but still sold at average of 33% below market value!
Bainbridge Home Value Details
Parcel Number Location Address Owner Name 2006 Market Value 2009 Market Value Home Value Decrease Loss Sold for Amount Following Incident When Sold % sale price below market value
02-27480017975 ENGLISH DRVALLEY ENERGY SYSTEMS CORP $142,000 $49,800 64.90%($92,200)
02-03040017820 ENGLISH DRBALOGH GREGORY L & ADAMS LISA A$148,600 $59,400 60.00%($89,200)
02-32280017915 KINGSWOOD DRPATZ DONNA M$168,100 $67,200 60.00%($100,900)
02-09550017888 ENGLISH DRBURNS ROBERT P & DEBBIE A$199,600 $79,800 60.00%($119,800)
02-23450017995 ENGLISH DRCZERNICKI PAUL & LENART JANIS$208,100 $83,200 60.00%($124,900)
02-29635017839 ENGLISH DRREIK ARTHUR H TOD $161,800 $64,700 60.00%($97,100)
02-09570017860 ENGLISH DRSTOVER GARY & JEANNE $200,800 $80,300 60.00%($120,500)
02-33410018019 ENGLISH DRSLACAS WILLIAM JR JR & DEBORAH A$209,800 $83,900 60.00%($125,900)
02-145610ENGLISH DRHABERLAND ELIZABETH J $29,500 $11,800 60.00%($17,700)
02-32210017889 ENGLISH DRSCHULTZ RICHARD H SR & $135,000 $54,000 60.00%($81,000)
02-12990017939 ENGLISH DRGAUB FRED R & LAURA M TRUSTEES$188,000 $75,200 60.00%($112,800)
02-06920017956 KINGSWOOD DRBRYANT GARY L &$213,000 $85,200 60.00%($127,800)07/8/2010
02-05420017969 KINGSWOOD DRCALO VINCENT E$182,000 $72,800 60.00%($109,200)02/5/2010
02-24140017922 ENGLISH DRHARROLD RANDALL W & ADIE KAREN L$226,200 $90,500 60.00%($135,700)
02-38140017936 KINGSWOOD DRVINCENTI NORMAN J &$208,700 $83,500 60.00%($125,200)
02-09540017938 ENGLISH DRDONALDSON JOAN M TOD $166,200 $66,500 60.00%($99,700)
02-41410017970 KINGSWOOD DRWOZNIAK GLENN P &$284,400 $113,800 60.00%($170,600)
02-08140017968 KINGSWOOD DRGREISL DAVID J$190,400 $76,200 60.00%($114,200)
02-26375018018 ENGLISH DRNEWMAN GARY JAMES & KATHLEEN ANN$154,400 $61,800 60.00%($92,600)
02-420040KINGSWOOD DRGREISL DAVID J$5,400 $2,200 59.30%($3,200)
02-07650017954 ENGLISH DRCOOPER RUTH A TRUSTEE $162,100 $70,900 56.30%($91,200)
02-32660017927 KINGSWOOD DRPROCHAZKA BOBBY J &$134,400 $80,600 40.00%($53,800)
02-35210017809 KINGSWOOD DRSABO THOMAS A &$157,900 $94,700 40.00%($63,200)
02-41770017823 KINGSWOOD DRHALL GREGORY D &$161,400 $96,800 40.00%($64,600)
02-08480017826 KINGSWOOD DRDAVIDSON JAMES W JR &$175,400 $105,200 40.00%($70,200)
02-22220017775 KINGSWOOD DRRENTZ TIMOTHY E &$220,400 $132,200 40.00%($88,200)
02-33780017835 KINGSWOOD DRSMITH VIRGINIA MAY TOD$148,700 $89,200 40.00%($59,500)
02-10380017795 KINGSWOOD DREDC BRENTON I I$154,700 $92,800 40.00%($61,900)
02-123100KINGSWOOD DRWELCH ROBERT C &$19,000 $11,400 40.00%($7,600)
02-15849017845 KINGSWOOD DRGOODING JUDITH F$250,000 $150,000 40.00%($100,000)
02-31920017961 KINGSWOOD DRSAVEL RICHARD S &$179,500 $107,700 40.00%($71,800)
02-02127017895 KINGSWOOD DRHANNAH STEVEN L &$206,800 $124,100 40.00%($82,700)
02-12320017796 KINGSWOOD DRWELCH ROBERT C &$204,300 $122,600 40.00%($81,700)
02-03120017890 KINGSWOOD DRBLASCHAK EUGENE DAVID$190,300 $114,200 40.00%($76,100)
02-05230017836 KINGSWOOD DRBUTERBAUGH KENNETH$193,600 $116,200 40.00%($77,400)
02-22660017866 KINGSWOOD DRLUNDSTROM ROY A &$185,100 $111,100 40.00%($74,000)
02-34190017949 KINGSWOOD DRBRADY COLLEEN M$162,600 $97,600 40.00%($65,000)
02-23640017971 KINGSWOOD DRDEGAETANO MELISSA A$161,600 $97,000 40.00%($64,600)
02-175170ENGLISH DRVLADIMIROFF BORIS $41,000 $41,000 0.00%$0
02-054100KINGSWOOD DRCALO VINCENT C &$400 $400 0.00%$0
02-191200KINGSWOOD DRRICKER EDWARD D$10,600 $10,600 0.00%$0 6,500.0012/16/200938.70%
02-31930017810 KINGSWOOD DRGILBERT REED S$160,700 $160,700 0.00%$0 011/23/2009
02-03043017840 ENGLISH DRMENARY MARK D LAURA J$238,900 $238,900 0.00%$0
02-03460017855 ENGLISH DRCUMPSTONE WILLIAM C & KERRY BETH$211,400 $211,400 0.00%$0
02-35230017865 KINGSWOOD DRWASHABAUGH RICHARD A &$173,300 $173,300 0.00%$0
02-27430017869 KINGSWOOD DRPAULUS DELORES$224,500 $224,500 0.00%$0
02-03470017871 ENGLISH DRENGLISH JUSTIN T & EMILY L$152,000 $152,000 0.00%$0 110,100.003/31/200827.60%
02-18250017875 KINGSWOOD DRROWE ROBERT P$201,500 $201,500 0.00%$0
02-14695017885 KINGSWOOD DRHALFACRE DOUGLAS WILLIAM$169,100 $169,100 0.00%$0
02-05215017896 KINGSWOOD DRBORDONARO FRANK T$211,200 $211,200 0.00%$0
02-09580017904 ENGLISH DRSZABO FRANK D $168,500 $168,500 0.00%$0
02-06320017905 ENGLISH DRPALAZZA JOHN & DANIELLE$189,000 $189,000 0.00%$0
02-05210017925 ENGLISH DRMAGUIRE CHRIS BOYER $222,700 $222,700 0.00%$0 08/29/2008
02-18308017926 KINGSWOOD DRJOHNSON THOMAS &$209,400 $209,400 0.00%$0
02-01338017955 ENGLISH DRWEBER ROBERT TRUSTEE $188,600 $188,600 0.00%$0
02-21940017990 ENGLISH DRJORDON THOMAS & CASSANDRA$115,600 $115,600 0.00%$0
02-24300018006 ENGLISH DRMC GREW JOAN TOD $126,800 $126,800 0.00%$0 07/6/2009
02-20460017937 KINGSWOOD DRPETHERBRIDGE GREGORY J$95,000 $119,800 -26.10%n/a
totals$6,489,800 $3,176,100 51.10%($3,313,700)
averages$165,517 $108,812 $0 ($58,135)33.10%